June 3, 2023


pets keep it coming

What Do Dogs Want? Social Choices and Varied Breeding for Better Welfare

6 min read

A comparison with village pet dogs highlights some of the approaches that pet dogs’ life could be enhanced.

Pet dogs, like this brown Poodle on a bed, have good lives, but compared to village dogs there could still be some improvement
Image: Lim Tiaw Leong/Shutterstock

By Zazie Todd PhD

This web site is made up of affiliate one-way links which signifies I might generate a fee on qualifying purchases at no expense to you.

Do pet canines have it all? They get to lounge about for most of the day, their meals are provided for them, and they can have infinite pets from their human beings. But are there methods that we could improve the welfare of pet puppies?   

A group of researchers has investigated this concern by evaluating pet puppies to village dogs in a paper in press in Applied Animal Conduct Science. Soon after all, canine existed as village puppies for centuries prior to any pet pet dogs arrived alongside, so the scientists say “the comparison could provide as a fantastic basis for examining the outcomes of the ‘petification’ of dogs.” 

Dr. Iben Meyer and Prof. Peter Sandøe (Dept of Veterinary and Animal Sciences, University of Copenhagen), two of the authors of the paper, advised me,

“In get to enhance the welfare of companion dogs, it is initially essential to identify that they basically frequently endure welfare-associated difficulties. Of program, modern companion pet dogs love numerous privileges by living with human beings in modern day city or suburban environments. Even so, they also have to pay a price tag for this. Human preferences for unique doggy “looks” can guide to major overall health challenges. Human requires for dogs to fit in with chaotic lifestyles, and anticipations of dogs’ social competencies, can lead to a range of genuine or perceived behavioural difficulties. 

“Our hope with this paper is to encourage guardians to acquire a new look at the pet dogs in front of them, and to look at: what are the requires and limitations of a species that, for much of the time it evolved, was not bred in accordance to human preferences, but somewhat was adapted to a way of life not that distinct from that enjoyed by modern day village canines?”


Comparing village canines to pet dogs

The scientists reviewed the literature to compare the lives of village canine with pet canines in the Worldwide North. They say they are not seeking to romanticize the life of village dogs. In point, pet puppies have many benefits, not minimum of which is fantastic veterinary treatment. Pet canines stay substantially more time than village dogs, many of which die as puppies and all round ordinarily only reside to 3-4 several years. A further gain for pet pet dogs is entry to excellent food and a lot more safety. 

But village canine have a great deal more liberty in conditions of what they do and where they go. 

The scientists focus on two strategies in which pet dogs may well have compromised welfare in contrast to village canines: the outcomes of breeding, and the social needs we set on pet pet dogs.

Breeding issues

Village canine can mate with other canine as they wish. In typical village puppies are medium-sized and appear really comparable, but they in fact have a great deal of genetic range. 

In distinction, most pet canine are bred via human preference. Breeding pedigrees is one thing that genuinely took off in Victorian times. When breeding decisions are produced mainly primarily based on looks it can have serious wellness effects. Despite the fact that pet dogs have a a lot broader variety of appearances, there is considerably significantly less genetic variety. 

Brachycephalic dogs (those with flat faces) are a prime example of well being difficulties involved with breeding. Pet dogs like this, this kind of as French Bulldogs and Pugs, can have a assortment of major issues together with Brachycephalic Obstructive Airway Syndrome (BOAS). Nevertheless people are generally drawn to these breeds for emotional reasons.  

Social factors

Village pet dogs have a extensive vary of diverse interactions with people today, both positive and unfavorable, and these may well fluctuate a lot dependent in which they are living. They are typically nicely socialized to persons and other dogs as puppies.

Pet dogs’ social life are managed by their guardians. We have substantial expectations, which include that dogs should really be alright getting remaining house on your own for parts of the day. It’s approximated that between 5 and 30% of pet dogs have separation-associated problems, whilst it is attainable that lots of guardians are unaware of their dog’s distress. Symptoms consist of destruction all-around the exits, vocalizing, and elimination even though the guardian is out. 

The researchers also point out that the pandemic may well have designed this difficulty even worse, with there being a time when puppies could not be effortlessly socialized. And with additional people doing work from property, quite a few pet canine have not bought made use of to remaining household by itself.

Pet pet dogs are predicted to usually be pleasant. As a social species, numerous pet pet dogs are missing out on prospects to interact with other puppies. Many folks do not socialize their pet adequate, may not give them more than enough probabilities to be sociable with other puppies or dogs, or conversely may possibly motivate their pup to interact with unfriendly canines leading to them to have a terrible working experience. Village canine have considerably extra alternative in interactions as they have the independence to go away, and they also have the opportunity to devote a good deal of time with other canine.

Lack of selection also impacts interactions in the residence, exactly where pet dogs are normally expected to be hugged and kissed, interactions that are far too total-on for numerous puppies. Eventually, if pet pet dogs are in a scenario where they growl or chunk, they may be euthanized. 

Pet pet welfare

The results of the recent examine highlight two important welfare difficulties for pet puppies. By being conscious of these issues, and paying out consideration to pet dogs’ social desires, people today can enhance their dog’s welfare. 

Recognizing that dogs are social creatures who need to have corporation, and that they require to have a option in interactions, will make a major variation to the puppy in your dwelling.

The scientists say the plan of pedigrees is not an issue, but extra care demands to be taken when picking puppies to breed in buy to boost the genetic diversity. One thing known as optimum contribution choice can be utilized to get the balance proper, but it calls for breeders to work with each other. 

The paper is timely as there is greater curiosity in animal welfare for pet canines. For case in point, people’s assessments of canine welfare count on the dog’s purpose, but they are inclined to put the welfare of their have pet as higher than that of other pet dogs (Cobb, 2020). And in A Dog’s Entire world, Jessica Pierce and Marc Bekoff take into consideration what lifetime would be like for dogs if people were being no for a longer time all around (glimpse out for an job interview with Pierce and Bekoff coming before long on this site).

The comparison in between pet puppies and village canine is an fascinating 1 and displays that despite the fact that our pooches have a lot of advantages in lifetime, there are a number of ways in which welfare could be improved. Pet canine might not have it all, soon after all. 

You could also like:

The street pet dogs of Bangkok  

How to select a puppy  

Why its purchaser beware when it will come to puppies (Psychology Nowadays)  

How to convey to if your pet in fact needs you to pet them (Psychology Now)  

Practical backlinks:

As an Amazon Associate I gain from qualifying purchases. As an Etsy affiliate, I gain from qualifying buys.


Cobb, M. L., Lill, A., & Bennett, P. C. (2020). Not all dogs are equal: Perception of canine welfare differs with context. Animal Welfare, 29(1), 27-35.

Meyer, I., Forkman, B., Fredholm, M., Glanville, C., Guldbrandtsen, B., Ruiz Izaguirre, E., Palmer, C. and Sandøe, P. (2022) Pampered pets or lousy bastards? The welfare of dogs kept as companion animals, Applied Animal Behaviour Science. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.applanim.2022.105640